Yankees vs Blue Jays All-Time Record: Yankees Lead 411-344

AL East rivalry
New York Yankees
Toronto Blue Jays
Yankees lead Blue Jays411to344since 1977

Retrosheet history through 2025, plus 13 final games from the current feed.

2026 season series: Yankees lead 7-6

By

Data updated 6 min read

At a glance

All-time since 1977 · current-feed analysis, 2002 to 2026

Yankees vs Blue Jays postseason head-to-head record

New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays have met 755 times since 1977, 4 times in the postseason. The playoff games are included in the all-time total, not added on top of it.

Postseason record
Blue Jays 3-1
4 postseason games since 1977
Playoff share
0.5%
Share of all meetings
Regular season
751
Recorded non-postseason meetings

Recent Games

Last 10 Games
Aug 23
NYY 8-3 TOR
NYY
Aug 22
NYY 3-4 TOR
TOR
Aug 21
NYY 3-1 TOR
NYY
Aug 16
TOR 3-4 NYY
NYY
Aug 15
TOR 4-1 NYY
TOR
Aug 14
TOR 3-1 NYY
TOR
Jun 14
TOR 3-8 NYY
NYY
Jun 13
TOR 1-3 NYY
NYY
Jun 12
TOR 8-5 NYY
TOR
May 21
NYY 0-2 TOR
TOR

Record since 2002

Season Split & Biggest Wins
Regular season vs Postseason record, plus each team's largest margin of victory
Regular Season434 games
236
198
Postseason4 games
1
3
New York Yankees Biggest Win
20–6+14 runs
Sep 15, 2020
Toronto Blue Jays Biggest Win
14–1+13 runs
Sep 23, 2020
Decade Breakdown
Choose a decade to scope the current-feed page
Season by Season
Season ↓NYY ↕TOR ↕Games ↕
20267613
202561117
20247613
20237613
202211819
202181119
20205510
201911819
201813619
201791019
201671219
201561319
201411819
201314519
201211718
201111718
201081018
200912618
20089918
200710818
200610818
200512618
200412719
200310919
200210919

All 25 seasons are shown in the table above.

Home / Away Split
131-87NYY HOME114-106TOR HOME
AWAY
106-114
NYY
AWAY
87-131
TOR
Retrosheet archiveComplete through 2025

New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays all-time record, 1977 to 2025

Explore how this matchup changed by decade, where each lineup produced its runs, and the games that pushed the rivalry record book. This archive is a separate source window from the current-feed sections above, which start in 2002.

Games
742
Peak inning
1
Record game
29 runs
Two source windows. Current-feed sections: 438 games from 2002 to 2026. History Lab: 742 Retrosheet games from 1977 to 2025. The first refreshes with current finals; Retrosheet's published archive currently ends in 2025.

Decade balance

Select an era to inspect pace, scoring and attendance.

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at www.retrosheet.org.

Open source archive

Betting Context

Betting context since 2002

How this pairing has settled: run margins, totals and break-even prices derived from its historical record. These are final-score frequencies, not results against a closing line. We do not hold historical sportsbook prices for these games.

One-run games
25.8%

Share of the 438 decided meetings settled by exactly one run.

Won by 2 or more
74.2%

A 2+ run margin crosses 1.5, but this is not a historical line result. Average gap: 3.5.

Average total
9.2runs

Final-score average without accounting for park, bullpen or weather.

Home side wins
55.9%

Share of decided meetings won by the listed home team.

Totals ladder

Where the combined score landed against the half-run lines a book normally posts. Half runs cannot push, so every meeting falls on one side.

LineOverUnderOver rate
7.5266172
60.7%
8.5Closest to even231207
52.7%
9.5179259
40.9%

Fair price from the base rate

The decimal price that corresponds exactly to each club's win share in this archive. It describes the record and does not estimate the next game.

New York Yankees
237 W · 54.1%1.85
Toronto Blue Jays
201 W · 45.9%2.18

A base rate is not a forecast. Starting pitchers, lineups, injuries and venue all matter more to a single game than a multi-season head-to-head record.

Last 20 meetings vs full history

One-run games
30%vs 25.8% full archive
+4.2% in the last 20
Won by 2 or more
70%vs 74.2% full archive
-4.2% in the last 20
Average total
8.3 runsvs 9.2 runs full archive
-0.9 runs in the last 20

Seasons 2025 to 2026. The comparison shows whether the last 20 final scores differ from the longer archive, without assigning a cause or predicting what comes next.

View the break-even percentages in another odds format with the odds converter, or compare current prices for Yankees and Blue Jays in the oddsmatcher.

Questions about this record: New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays

When did the New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays first play each other?

The Retrosheet archive's first recorded meeting for this pairing is Apr 18, 1977, when Toronto Blue Jays won 5-1 away to New York Yankees. The archive covers 742 meetings from 1977 through 2025. The current feed starts in 2002 and is reported separately.

About Erik Andersson

Erik Andersson is SharkBetting's Content & Marketing Specialist. His published work focuses on betting methodology, market analysis, regulation and consumer education.

The source windows, derivations and update process for this data page are documented in the methodology above.

View full profile →

Methodology & Data Sources

Current MLB game logs come from the balldontlie API and cover the 2002 season onward. Scores and schedule anomalies are checked against the official MLB Stats API. Spring training is excluded, while results from earlier franchise identities are merged into the current club.

The all-time record and the History Lab use Retrosheet game logs through 2025, with inning lines, team totals, attendance, duration and ballpark fields when available. Final games after 2025 come from the current feed, and every section built on that feed alone is labeled as starting in 2002.

The betting context summarizes completed final scores only. It contains no sportsbook closing lines and summarizes only completed games. Report a possible error through our contact page with the matchup and game date.

Read the full H2H data methodology →

Last updated Sources: balldontlie, MLB Stats API, Retrosheet

New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays have met 438 times in this archive, which covers the 2002 season onward.