New York Islanders vs Pittsburgh Penguins Head-to-Head

Penguins built their historical edge pre-2005, winning 80 of 171 decided meetings (47%) (plus 22 ties). In the shootout era they are 69-54 against each other (56% Penguins). 22 historical ties live in the all-time ledger, all predating the 2005 shootout rule. Postseason history is deep: 35 playoff games between the two franchises. Games average a 2.4-goal margin, with the largest blowout coming via Islanders' 9-goal win. Across the last 20 decided meetings Islanders hold a 13-7 edge, suggesting the modern balance leans their way. The 1980s produced the deepest sample with 71 recorded meetings, more than any other decade in the series. Their first recorded meeting fell in 1972, so the rivalry has spanned 54 seasons of NHL history. Most recent result: Penguins won 8-3 on Mar 30, 2026. Through the 2020s Islanders have led 17-15 between the teams.